What Is the Most Loved Dessert on Thanksgiving?

When it comes to Thanksgiving, the star of the table is often the turkey—crispy, golden, and perfectly seasoned. But once the plates are cleared and everyone is leaning back with full bellies, there’s one thing everyone still makes room for: dessert. Thanksgiving sweets hold a special place in the holiday tradition, and people across the country look forward to their favorite indulgence all year long.

So, what is the favorite Thanksgiving dessert? Let’s dive into the treats that top the holiday charts and why they’ve become such beloved staples.

Pumpkin Pie: The Undisputed Classic

If Thanksgiving had an official dessert, it would be pumpkin pie. Made with warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves, pumpkin pie captures the essence of fall in every bite. Its creamy texture paired with flaky crust and a dollop of whipped cream makes it the go-to dessert for many families.
Its long-standing tradition also contributes to its popularity—it’s been served on Thanksgiving tables since the early days of American history.

Pecan Pie: Sweet, Sticky, and Southern

Right behind pumpkin pie sits another crowd favorite: pecan pie. With its rich, caramel-like filling topped with toasted pecans, this Southern classic brings a delightful crunch and sweetness to the dessert table.
Many people love pecan pie for its indulgent flavor and the satisfying contrast between its gooey center and nutty topping.

Apple Pie: An All-American Favorite

For those who crave something fruity and comforting, apple pie takes the spotlight. With warm baked apples, cinnamon, and a buttery crust, this iconic dessert hits the nostalgic heartstrings—mixing holiday tradition with classic American flavor.
Some families serve it with vanilla ice cream (the perfect pairing known as à la mode), making it even more irresistible.

Cheesecake: A Creamy Holiday Favorite

Cheesecake might not be the most traditional Thanksgiving dessert, but it has become a modern favorite. From pumpkin cheesecake to caramel pecan or classic New York style, this dessert offers versatility that appeals to all kinds of palates.
Smooth, decadent, and rich—it’s no surprise more families are making room for it on their dessert tables.

Sweet Potato Pie: A Cultural Classic

Especially beloved in the South, sweet potato pie carries deep cultural roots and rich flavor. Its smooth, lightly spiced filling is similar to pumpkin pie but with a naturally sweeter, earthier flavor.
For many households, Thanksgiving simply isn’t complete without it.

Modern Favorites Making Their Way to the Table

Thanksgiving dessert traditions evolve, and many families now include treats like:

• Pumpkin rolls
  
  
• Chocolate cream pie
  
  
• Cinnamon bundt cake
  
  
• Bread pudding
  
  
• Tiramisu twist recipes with fall spices
  
  

These newer additions bring a fun and delicious variety to the celebration.

So, What’s the Most Favorite Overall?

While the competition is strong, pumpkin pie remains the most beloved Thanksgiving dessert in most American homes.
It’s iconic, nostalgic, and perfectly captures the flavors of fall. But the beauty of Thanksgiving is the variety—every family has its own traditions, and every dessert tells a story.

Final Thoughts

Thanksgiving desserts are more than sweet treats—they’re memories, traditions, and comfort on a plate. Whether your favorite is the classic pumpkin pie or a unique family specialty, dessert is always the perfect ending to a warm holiday celebration.